Thursday, May 7, 2015

Window of Lies, Doors of Hope

Window of Lies, Doors of Hope
“ A Temporary Matter” written by Jhumpa Lahiri, is about the experience of  despair and woe, as well as secrets people keep from one another. Main characters as well as husband and wife, Shukumar and Shoba are grieving over the loss of their first child, who passed six moths earlier. During this time, they find themselves disconnecting from friends, as well as one another. Shukumar uses his time to finish his dissertation and Shoba fills her time by working more.
Having solid communication in any relationship is crucial and very important, but even more so for a marriage to prosper, which is prevalent theme in the story. The pain and devastation due to the loss of a child causes a large communication barrier between Shukumar and Shoba. The roar of silence is ultimately what dismantles them, not just as a couple, but individually. Because of this, their relationship begins to fail, because of the lack of shared experiences. They both have a pocket full of secrets and the ones that are finally expressed, create a huge change in their dynamic. They decided that in the mist of the blackout that lasted for five days, they would reveal things to one another, they have never shared. Being married and grieving the lost of a child can destroy the strongest of people, so it can affect a relationship or marriage in many ways. 
The lies seemed to start out as innocent, for instance, when Shoba tells Shukumar that when they first started dating, she peeked inside of his address book to see if she was written in it. Another example was when Shukumar tells Shoba that on their first date, he forgot to tip the waiter and the following morning he left tip money with he manager. Progressively the secrets became more and more revealing. The following night, Shoba told her husband that when his mother visited, she told him she was going to work late, while in reality she went out with a friend. The morning of the fifth night, they received a letter stating that their power would be reinstated. Although they received this news, they still decided to eat dinner in darkness. Still continuing with the sharing of secrets, Shoba says, “I want you to see my face when I tell you this,” she used these same words to tell him she was pregnant.  The light goes on, and Shoba expressed her plans of moving out. This stimulated a multitude of different emotions in Shukmar. In the heat of it all, the one thing he promised himself, he went against. He announced the sex of their child. He was a boy. “Our baby was a boy. His skin was more red than brown.He had black hair on his head. He weighed almost five pounds. His fingers were curled shut, just like yours in the night.” (Jhumpa pg.11) Shoba turned the lights off once more, and they sob together, “for the things they now knew.” (Jhumpa, pg.12)
“A Temporary Matter” is told from third-person perspective of Shukumar. The reading infers that the events taken place are though his experiences, although the narrator is omniscient.  The story begins as a memory.  With each object that is touched my Shakumar, he is brought back to a time, a happier time, in the couples lives. An example is him touching birthday candles used during the blackout, it brought him back to the surprise party Shoba planned for him. Although this story is mainly told through Shakumar, it is refreshing to hear Shobas confession at the end of the story, and the readers are able to appreciate her point of the view about terminating their marriage.
Just as place, theme, and attitude are important in conveying a message and capturing a story; environment is of equal importance. Being surrounded by darkness (literally), acts as a metaphor for the couples relationship. It acted like a safe place for the couple to express themselves freely. Considering, both individuals are in a dark place; in terms of the death of their child. Another example of  environment is how towards the final days in the dark, the snow they had been experiencing; began to melt, symbolizing the release of grief they both felt. According to American Pregnancy Association, experiencing a stillbirth affects over 25,000 families each year. (American Pregnancy Association, Jan 2014, pg1)
A very prominent part of Indian culture is food, which also has a huge role on the story. Shoba and Shukmar would travel to nearby markets, Shoba would come home and create magnificent meals for them. Shoba would create meals that were more than enough for the two of them. By doing this, their house was always open to others. After the death of their child, Shukumar started paying less attention to the meals his wife would create for him. This showed the lack of love and affection between the couple.  
The brilliant title of this story “A Temporary Matter” interests the readers on different levels. Of course the story is developed around the ideas of a happy marriage coming to an end, and then fatality of a child, the story is mostly focused on he little things in life. The title within itself acts almost as a summary of the story. The power outage might have brought the couple closer, but it was unfortunately only a “temporary matter”. The entire story is made up of small ‘insignificant’ memories or thoughts, but they hold the same weight as the confessions of not being in love the same way. Other thing
Losing a child is one of the most tragic event to happen to a family. According to Marriage and Family Therapist, Jean Galica, “Each year more than 300,000 children die in America, leaving thousands of families to cope with this tragedy” (Galcia, pg.1). She explained this death as a ball of yarn, each family member represents a specific piece of yarn, when one member dies the entire ball must be unwound, the strand removed and the ball put back together, but the ball can never be created the way it once was. Through this process, tension arises and a great deal of stress is put on the family and this can cause marital strains.  One of the most common myths about a child’s death is that the marriage between the parents will eventually end in divorce. Whether or not the marriage becomes better or worse it is up to the parents, but the marriage will never be the same as before the child’s death. 
It can seem that there is too much expected out a marriage relationship. No one can fulfill each and every need of their spouse. Being able to be their for your spouses every want and need is unrealistic and this can for in the feelings of  “resentment, anger, hurt, and abandonment”. (Galcia, pg.1) Although grieving parents experience the situation together, there can be a profound state of isolation present. Unlike any other death in a family, grieving over a child is the most difficult. The average grief stage for the death of a spouse is two years, while four to five years for the death of a child. 
Of course females and males handle the grieving stages differently. On average, females tend to grieve longer and more intensely. The reason for this, is because mothers are usually with the child on more “day to day intimacies”. This creates more reminders of the death of their child. It can be as simple as “one less plate to set at the dinner table, grocery shopping (going to purchase the child’s favorite food)… but the list carries on.” Males tend to focus more on specifics like tasks, oppose to relationships. They see things through work not emotional ties. That is why their grief isn't as exposed. Society instills the notion that men should not cry. They are known as the protector, and have to keep up a strong front for their family. It is acceptable for women to cry, but men must show strength.  
“Grief in males seems to decline much more rapidly than in females. In fact, grief in females after the death of a child tends to be particularly intense for about two years after the child’s death. So, while the husband’s grief is decreasing, his wife’s grief is either increasing or at least remaining constant. This needs to be recognized and understood by both spouses as a normal phenomenon.” (Jean Galica M.A,  pg 1, n.d)
This relates to the story “A Temporary Matter” because there was a specific part of the story where Shoba reminisces about a time where she went to a rice ceremony for a baby and how the baby spent the entire time crying. This of course gets Shukumar to think about their own baby, the baby they were supposed to have a rice ceremony for. This leaves Shukumar feeling melancholy, but he doesn't act or express these feelings. In the story, the reader doesn't really witness too much emotion from Shukmar until the very ending, when the couple turn out the light and cry together. Shukmar had different thought about what it'd be like to be a parent. 
“As the cab sped down Beacon Street, he imagined a day when he and Shoba might need to buy a station wagon of their own, to cart their children back and forth from music lessons and dentist
appointments. He imagined himself gripping the wheel, as Shoba turned around to hand the children juice boxes. Once, these images of parenthood had troubled Shukumar, adding to his anxiety that he was still a student at thirty-five. But that early autumn morning, the trees still heavy with bronze leaves, he welcomed the image for the first time.” ( Jhumpa Lahiri, pg. 9)

This story shows a multitude of different emotions. It focuses on how lies and deception and with holding information can change a relationship, it shows what the loss of a child can do to a marriage, and it also shows it is possible to make things work if they are discussed. 

No comments:

Post a Comment